The rock-n-roll nurse is gone. America booted Amanda Overmyer and kept the talentless but hot Kristy Lee Cook on tonight’s “American Idol.” Where is the justice?
Still, the bottom three wasn’t a surprise. Rock chicks Overmyer and Carly Smithson are too hard-edged to be the next American Idol talented as they may be. The voters are looking for the girl next door — Brooke White — not a girl who can drink them under the table. or beat them in arm wrestling
Tonight’s show was tortuous. Idiotic phone calls, Idol Gives Back and Kellie Pickler padded the show out so it could stretch out 10 minutes of original content into a half hour.